H.R. 4670 does little to help Dreamers or to alleviate hunger

January 30, 2018
We urge Congress to embrace smarter immigration and border enforcement policy. Photo: Jeffrey Austin

By Marlysa D. Gamblin

The Securing America’s Future Act (H.R. 4670) was introduced as a way to “fix our broken immigration system.” However, this bill would transform our immigration system in ways that would increase hunger and do little to reduce factors that push people to migrate.

As Bread for the World has said in the past, any attempt to fix immigration must address hunger on both sides of the border—including international push factors. Otherwise, we risk ignoring the root causes of our "broken system" altogether. This legislation would increase hunger in many ways, in part because the bill:

  1. Does not provide a permanent solution for Dreamers. The legislation allows Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients to receive a 3-year renewable legal status—not permanent U.S. citizenship. Unfortunately, this only temporarily protects 800,000 out of 11 million undocumented immigrants in the United States. In addition, it requires Dreamers to maintain earning levels of at least 125 percent of the federal poverty line to stay in the United States. These provisions place them in a constant state of uncertainty, especially if they were to lose a job or unable to find a job that meet these requirements. On top of that, not receiving citizenship also prevents them from having vital supports, including unemployment insurance to keep them at this earning level if they were to lose a job.  
  2. Separates families by ignoring the parents. At Bread, we have affirmed the importance of family unity and improved access to legal pathways to citizenship. Since this bill does little to protect parents, at least 4.5 million American children would be at risk of having their parents deported—directly increasing their likelihood of experiencing hunger.
  3. Diminishes humanitarian protections for asylum seekers. Research that shows 80 percent of women coming from Central America should receive asylum status based on “a credible fear of persecution or torture,” but are refused it. This bill makes it even harder for women and unaccompanied minor children who are leaving extreme violence and poverty from obtaining the proper status—instead resulting in their detention and deportation to countries with extreme levels of food-insecurity. This is another reason why addressing root causes of forced migration is so critical to resolving immigration.
  4. Focuses disproportionately on increasing expensive border security measures instead of addressing root causes of migration. There is mixed evidence that increased border security would reduce forced migration. However, there is significant evidence that migration to the United States is largely due to push factors, including extreme hunger, poverty, and violence causing people to flee their home countries. Yet, we continue to focus our efforts on solutions that won’t yield the same results to reduce illegal migration. Border patrol funding is already 17 times the amount of aid to Central America. This bill proposes increasing border funding by $30 billion. When instead, we could prioritize funding to address factors in Central America that push people to flee to the United States.

Marlysa D. Gamblin is the domestic advisor for policy and programs for specific populations at Bread for the World Institute.

This bill would transform our immigration system in ways that would increase hunger and do little to reduce factors that push people to migrate.

from our Resource Library

For Education

  • The Nourishing Effect

    Hunger and food insecurity add at least $160 billion a year to U.S. healthcare costs.

  • Mass Incarceration: A Major Cause of Hunger

    Mass incarceration has far-reaching effects in the United States. It poses a significant barrier to ending U.S. hunger and poverty by 2030—a goal the United States adopted in 2015. But the connection is not always obvious.

  • Advancing Nutrition through Food Aid Reform

    The United States has long been a global leader in responding to humanitarian emergencies. Food assistance that includes nutritious food for pregnant women and young children is both a life-and-death matter for individuals and an economic imperative for countries.

For Faith

  • Unity Declaration on Racism and Poverty

    A diverse body of Christian leaders calls on the churches and Congress to focus on the integral connection.

    Dear Members of Congress,

    As the president and Congress are preparing their plans for this year, almost 100 church leaders—from all the families of U.S. Christianity—are...

  • In Times Like These … A Pan-African Christian Devotional for Public Policy Engagement

    This devotional guide invites deepened relationship with and among Pan-Af­rican people and elected leaders in the mission to end hunger and poverty.

  • Sermon by David Beckmann at Duke University Chapel

    Remarks delivered October 1, 2017 at Duke University Chapel in Chapel Hill in North Carolina.

    Thank you for inviting me to preach here at Duke University Chapel. And I especially want to thank the Bread for the World members who have come this morning.

    Bruce Puckett urged...

For Advocacy

  • Grassroots Advocacy Toolkit

    A set of how-to sheets for carrying out advocacy and fact sheets on the current issues Bread for the World is working on.

    For new and current Bread grassroots hunger activists.

    Ideal as a starter toolkit for new Bread activists or as a set of updates for current activists.


  • Sentencing Reform and Corrections Act of 2017

    Unnecessarily long prison sentences, combined with the lack of rehabilitative programs for people in prison, exacerbate hunger, poverty, and existing inequalities.

    Overly harsh mandatory minimum prison sentences have contributed to the rapid increase of our country’s prison population. The...

  • Health Care Is a Hunger Issue

    Learn more about the principles that Bread for the World supports regarding health reform.